WHO’S CARRYING THE LIABILITY? THE FAAAA AND THE CHANGING LEGAL LANDSCAPE FOR THE THIRD-PARTY LOGISTICS INDUSTRY.

By: Associate Editor, Alexandra Rolf

Introduction:

The third-party logistics (“3PL”) industry is the hidden gem of the United States transportation system. Freight brokers, a major part of the 3PL industry, connect shippers seeking to transport goods with motor carriers capable of moving those goods.[i]  In doing so, freight brokers facilitate the communications, operations, and logistics between shippers and motor carriers.[ii] For decades, however, freight brokers have operated in a legal gray area of state negligence laws and federal preemption defenses, with courts nationwide divided on whether an injured plaintiff could hold brokers accountable for choosing unsafe carriers.[iii] This created the question: when a motor carrier causes an accident, to what extent should the freight broker that selected the carrier be held responsible?

In May of 2025, the landmark Supreme Court case Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC ruled on that very question, and changed the transportation world for everyone, especially freight brokers.[iv] On the same day of the Supreme Court’s decision in Montgomery, the Supreme Court of Texas ruled on In re Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.[v] In Home Depot, the court addressed the complementary question, whether commercial shippers who engage federally regulated motor carriers to transport ordinary goods owe common-law duty of care to motorists injured by the carrier’s negligence.[vi]  Together, these decisions reshaped the boundaries of tort liability across the logistics chain.

Background:

            In 1994, Congress enacted the Federal Aviation Administration Act (“FAAAA”) to eliminate competitive disadvantages faced by motor carriers relative to air carriers and to address inefficiencies caused by non-uniform state regulation.[vii] The FAAAA broadly preempts state laws related to “a price, route, or service of any motor carrier (other than a carrier affiliated with a direct air carrier covered by section 41713(b)(4)) or any motor private carrier, broker, or freight forwarder with respect to the transportation of property.”[viii]  In addition to FAAAA, Congress enacted the safety exception. Under 49 U.S.C. §14501(c)(2)(A), the FAAAA “shall not restrict the safety regulatory authority of a State with respect to motor vehicles.”[ix] These two provisions, enacting broad federal preemption paired with a safety exception, have opened the door to years of litigation over whether state negligent-hiring claims against brokers fell within the preemption clause or survived under the safety exception.

The Effect of Montgomery & Home Depot:

            In Montgomery, the plaintiff was severely injured when a driver, employed by Caribe Transport and hired by C.H. Robinson (a 3PL), veered off course and struck the plaintiff’s tractor-trailer.[x] The Caribe Transport, hired to run this load by C.H. Robinson, had a conditional safety rating and documented deficiencies in driver qualification, hours of service, and maintenance.[xi] The case presented the Supreme Court with the question of whether a negligent-hiring claim against a company that selected another company to transport goods falls within the FAAAA’s safety exception.[xii] The Supreme Court held that it does, and that a claim that one company negligently hired another to transport goods is not preempted by the FAAAA because States retain authority to regulate safety “with respect to motor vehicles” under the FAAAA safety exception.[xiii]

            While Montgomery appeared to resolve the decades\-long debate surrounding freight broker liability, the Supreme Court of Texas complicated the liability landscape that same day by addressing a related but distinct question in In re Home Depot U.S.A, Inc.[xiv] In Home Depot, the plaintiff’s wife was killed when the motorcycle on which she was riding collided with a tractor-trailer owned and operated by Werner Enterprises.[xv] At the time of the accident, Werner was a federally regulated motor carrier and independent contractor that was hired by Home Depot to transport goods between its retail stores.[xvi] The question before the Texas Supreme Court was whether a commercial shipper that hires an independent motor carrier owes a common-law duty to motorists injured by that carrier’s negligence.[xvii] The Texas Court held that an independent contractor or shipper that engages in a commercial transaction with an independent, federally regulated motor carrier to transport ordinary goods, owes no common-law duty of care to motorist injured by the carrier’s negligence.[xviii]  Thus, while Montgomery addressed whether federal law preempts state-law negligent-selection claims against freight brokers, In re Home Depot addressed whether a commercial shipper owes an underlying common-law duty of care when hiring an independent motor carrier.[xix]

What Does This Mean for The 3PLs?

            The impact of Montgomery on the 3PL industry is significant. By allowing negligent-hiring claims against freight brokers to proceed under FAAAA’s safety exception, the decision increases brokers’ potential exposure to liability arising from their carrier-selection decisions.[xx] As a result, brokers may need to exercise greater scrutiny when vetting motor carriers and maintain more thorough documentation of their selection processes.[xxi] Especially for smaller freight brokerage firms, this increased exposure presents a special type of burden, as their resources and lack of compliance infrastructure necessary to implement extensive carrier-vetting procedures and defend against negligent-hiring claims leaves them vulnerable. 

However, the ruling of Montgomery does not necessarily mean that every participant in the transportation chain will face the same expanded liability. Instead, the distinction between Montgomery and In re Home Depot lies in the role each party plays in arranging transportation. Montgomery permits negligent-selection claims against freight brokers under the applicable safety exception.[xxii] In re Home Depot establishes that commercial shippers do not owe a common-law duty of care merely because they hire an independent, federally regulated motor carrier to transport ordinary, nonhazardous goods.[xxiii] Considered together, these decisions drawn an important distinction between freight brokers who arrange transportation through motor carriers and commercial shippers who directly hire independent motor carriers.[xxiv] For freight brokers and 3PLs acting in a brokerage capacity, this distinction creates greater potential exposure to negligent-selection liability, emphasizing the importance of more rigorous carrier-vetting procedures, greater documentation requirements, and increased compliance costs.[xxv]

As the transportation industry adjusts to this evolving landscape, the distinction between the responsibilities of freight brokers, commercial shippers, and motor carriers will become increasingly significant. Together, Montgomery and In re Home Depot illustrate that liability within the transportation industry is not uniform but instead depends on the specific role and legal obligations of each participant.[xxvi] For freight brokers and 3PLs operating in a brokerage capacity, this means carrier selection is not merely an operational decision, but one that carries potential legal consequences. As a result, freight brokers must be increasingly mindful of their carrier-vetting procedures and the potential liability arising from negligent carrier selection. Ultimately these decisions highlight the evolving legal responsibilities within the transportation industry and the importance of understanding where liability begins and ends.

[i] Sam Nardi, The Role of Freight Brokers in the 3PL Industry, Speedy Freight (July 7, 2025), https://us.speedyfreight.com/the-role-of-freight-brokers-in-the-3pl-industry/.

[ii] Id.

[iii] Tyson Fisher, Supreme Court Just Raised the Stakes for Freight Brokers Hiring Unsafe Carriers, Land Line Media (May 14, 2026), https://landline.media/supreme-court-just-raised-the-stakes-for-freight-brokers-hiring-unsafe-carriers/.

[iv] Id.

[v] Steven Moreno, Texas Supreme Court Rules in Favor if Passive Shippers in In re Home Depot, Cozen, (May 18, 2026), https://www.cozen.com/news-resources/publications/2026/texas-supreme-court-rules-in-favor-of-passive-shippers-in-in-re-home-depot.

[vi] In re Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., 735 S.W.3d 719, 721 (2026).

[vii] Montgomery v. Caribe Transp. II, LLC, 608 U.S. 219, 222 (2026).

[viii] 49 U.S.C.S. § 14501 (c)(1) (LexisNexis).

[ix] 49 U.S.C.S. § 14501 (LexisNexis).

[x] Montgomery, 608 U.S. at 219.

[xi] Id. at 225.

[xii] Id. at 222.

[xiii] Id. at 219.

[xiv] Marc Bardack, Wayne Melnick & Xander Melnick, The New Landscape of Freight Broker Liability, Freeman, Mathis & Gary (Sept. 1, 2026), https://www.fmglaw.com/business-litigation/a-new-look-at-freight-broker-liability/.

[xv] In re Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., 735 S.W.3d at 721.

[xvi] Id.

[xvii] Id. at 22.

[xviii] Id. at 23.

[xix] Bardack et. al., supra note xiv.

[xx] Id.

[xxi] Id.

[xxii] Montgomery, 608 U.S. at 219.

[xxiii] In re Home Depot U.S.A., Inc., 735 S.W.3d at 725.

[xxiv] Bardack et. al., supra note xiv.

[xxv] Id.

[xxvi] Id.

Next
Next

Restricting the Historical Narrative: Private Agreements, Public Figures, and the Michael Jackson Biopic